They hold their mommy to a location correct outside of the restroom and you can Jenna states it is at that time, she takes a cordless cellular phone out of their mother’s putting on a costume place, and you may reconnects towards 911 driver

Fitzpatrick believes Jenna drops the phone and the telephone call grabs, seconds later on, the specific moment when she basic observes the woman mommy: as Dr. It’s after that she allows sagging a-cry regarding absolute pain:

“Given that humdrum as it is to listen, it is inconceivable you to one to call was anything other than a good declaration of shame up against the lady dad,” told you Fitzpatrick.

Nevertheless the protection states the same name proves Dr. Neulander’s innocence –if Jenna runs into the bathroom, there is absolutely no bloodstream towards the wall space yet. Jenna testifies she picks up the telephone by toilet, falls it because is not working while you are rushing to greatly help the girl father. On the safety evaluate, that is where Jenna sees blood into, and you will up to, the woman mother. This is when she yells, “You will find blood everywhere. “

“The brand new defense’s take on that’s you to definitely this lady mom can be acquired, before the woman, and you will the woman is reacting in order to the girl mom, the blood that’s on her behalf mom and perhaps bloodstream toward wall structure and on a floor as well,” told you Stevens.

“You to aids the idea that the very first time she saw bloodstream, she is actually looking at the woman mother,” Axelrod indexed to help you Stevens.

The new D.An excellent, regardless if, doesn’t faith Jenna you will definitely try everything she states have inked within the 13 moments the newest 911 name is actually on the keep. Fitzpatrick tried it themselves and you will says it got your about fifty moments.

You will find others part of Jenna’s testimony that can easily be extremely important. She informs this new jury one to since their dad was looking after her mom from the rooms, she noticed him cut off a bloodstream-soaked shirt and you can place they to the side. Now remember, new safety ideal you to definitely putting so it bloody clothing Match what is might have triggered a few of the bloodstream splatter throughout the rooms. However the top has never been discover.

“She would say zero,” Fitzpatrick said. “I do not think within her brain Jenna believes you to the lady father did so it. I do believe this woman is authored a defensive industry in her own notice where mommy slipped and you may decrease regarding bath.”

“I am concerned they are having a difficult a reaction to the brand new misery with the woman. . They know that the girl wishes these to vote not guilty. And know that that it 60-plus-year-dated accused is unlikely to reoffend,” Fitzpatrick said. “And all of men and women emotions can enjoy toward detriment of instance that become confirmed past a good doubt.”

The newest Verdict

Immediately following eight arduous days of testimony, Region Attorneys Costs Fitzpatrick addressed brand new jury one final time to possess closure objections, inquiring them to pay close attention to new physical proof — specifically the fresh blood splatter for the wall space plus the injuries so you’re able to Leslie Neulander’s body.

“While i said a couple of times about demo, Leslie tend to consult with you, people and men. You have to hear the girl,” the guy advised Axelrod. “And to and listen carefully on the terms regarding Jenna Neulander where critical 911 label.”

But there’s one thing the fresh D.A. couldn’t share with this new jury: exactly what he candidates try the fresh purpose one delivered Robert Neulander on an effective murderous frustration one to day. Detectives read away from a buddy of your own Neulander family one to Leslie try planning on signing a lease getting an alternate flat with the the day she passed away.

“Leslie try on her solution. Referring to not a man that handle one,” Fitzpatrick informed Axelrod.